Zit Seng's Blog

A Singaporean's technology and lifestyle blog

Not Enough Electricity In SAF Camp

I read with amusement the BMTC commander’s reply to a forum letter to review the “no-charger rule” for National Service recruits. He said the mass charging of mobile phones would mean using multi-adaptors and extension cords, which increases the risks of overheating. Really? BMTC doesn’t have enough electricity and/or sockets to go around to support mobile phone charging?

Let’s do some math. Suppose every recruit has a power hungry gadget needing to be charged. The sort that draws 2.1A (at 5V). The mains runs at 230VAC. I know it’s not a simple straight-forward Power = Current x Voltage formula here when it comes to converting between DC to AC. But some web resource tells me that it should work out to 0.0643A, depending on what kind of transformer you use. (I’m not electrically trained… so I hope I’m making sense here.)

0.0643A at 230VAC is pretty small. A single 13A circuit can support some 202 such power adapters.

Reasonably, how many multi-adaptors and extension cords do you expect to chain from a single power socket? I hear now the BMTC bunks are quite luxurious. No more whole platoon in one bunk. They house only like, maybe, 20 in one bunk? So let’s say these 20 recruits shared a single 13A power socket, like as if the entire bunk has got no other power supply, that’s only going to draw 1.286A. Overheating from 1.286A of current?

Tripping (i.e. falling down) hazard from multitudes of extension cords, perhaps. I’m not sure if overheating would be an appreciable concern.

This sounds like a case of just wanting to keep the rule for the sake of wanting rules.

I think, if the Colonel does not turn on his air-conditioner, perhaps the SAF could afford the electricity for 202 desperate recruits to keep their gadgets juiced up.

I wonder if the SAF can be more “welfare” with recruits? Does the no-charger rule also apply to non-recruits? If not, why?

Ref: Straits Times (screenshot of letter in the above)

1 thought on “Not Enough Electricity In SAF Camp

  1. I think the main reason for the no charger rule is because they don’t want the recruits to keep using their smartphone. BMT is supposed to get the recruits to get use to army life. The training is tough and they want the recruits to spend their free time resting and not using their smartphones.

    Anyway, its just for BMT. Depending on where they are posted after BMT, most units allow the soldiers to bring chargers to camp. So just endure the first few months of NS. Won’t die 1 lah.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

View Comment Policy